I would suggest first replacing aLL of the 1157's.
In my sedan, I replaced one with a used bulb from my Accord, but it stayed on (dash light). I tried several mmore and concluded I would need to get some new ones. If you replace all 4 at the same time, it should go away (what I did in the sedan)
I went to my local dealer last night (PARKLANE ACURA in Kelowna) and asked the service manager about my brake lamp light... He said he knew what the problem was, pulled each bulb out and flicked them until he came to one that had a loose filament... He said it is a common problem that the filament breaks off at one end, but makes contact until it gets jiggled... That's why all my brake lights were working when the car wasn't moving !! He gave me a new bulb for free and told me to have a great day !!!
Parklane Acura's service has always been second to none... They even have the lowest shop rates in Kelowna !!!