I went to put my crankshaft pulley back on, and noticed that it didn't clear the notch in the timing belt cover. It had actually dug into it when the yard ran the engine! I looked it over really close, and looked at pics of the 3.5's on here, and I think I have the wrong pulley!! Can anyone tell from these pics?
This is where it dug into the timing cover:
This is where it dug into the timing cover: