I am getting some new tires. and want to know if its worth it getting the tire replacement plan for 9.95 per tire.. The plan is from "just tires" and it covers free flat repair and free replacement of tire if unfixable. Its about 325 total so about 80per tire w/o the plan. is it worth the extra 40 to get it???
Re: Is it worth it to get a Tire replacement Plan?
Originally posted by MarriedMikeb120 I am getting some new tires. and want to know if its worth it getting the tire replacement plan for 9.95 per tire.. The plan is from "just tires" and it covers free flat repair and free replacement of tire if unfixable. Its about 325 total so about 80per tire w/o the plan. is it worth the extra 40 to get it???
Thanks in advance.
I dunno.... most tires places will offer free rotation every 10000km and free flat repair w/ the purchase of tires. If the tire is unfixable then it should be under warranty.... sounds like kind of a scam to get another $40 out of you. If you are spending that much on tires you should be confident that they will not fail..... it is a very important part of the vehicle (if not the most important)
But a warranty won't cover all instances, for example if you get a puncture in the sidewall or towards the edge of the tread. In this case the tire becomes unfixable. Personally, I don't think it's a scam. It will more than pay for itself after one time if you ever have to replace a tire. On the other hand, I don't think it's entirely essential and wouldn't lose any sleep if I didn't get the protection plan.
I was actually refering to the tire manufacturer's warranty that covers X number of miles. A puncture or other similar unfixable incident wouldn't be covered under the tire's warranty. In this case, the replacement plan would be a benefit as you would get to replace that tire for free when you would normally have to shell out the $$$ for a new tire otherwise.
I would try to see what all the terms of the plan are, i.e., I'm sure it doesn't cover normal wear and tear, but does it include vandalism?
Car 1: 07 TSX
Car 2: 08 Odyssey
Car 3: The roller skate
iTrader Score: 1 reviews
At $10 a tire it may be worth it, but consider my experience. Had a new set of Michlins on the Legend and went on a trip to N.E. Hit a big chunk of metal on I-95 in Conn at 4:30 in the morning, 3" gash through the side wall. Place where I bought the tires does not have outlets in N.E. so I had to buy a tire anyways and they didn't have a match for the Mich so I just bought the cheapest. I did not have a replacement plan but the car was full of luggage and wedding presents so I couldn't carry the ruined tire back for inspection even if I had a plan to cover it.
In 36 years of driving this was the only time I had an unfixable tire.
I like my little red roller skate.
The AutoGuide.com network consists of the largest network of enthusiast-owned enthusiast-operated automotive communities.
AutoGuide.com provides the latest car reviews, auto show coverage, new car prices, and automotive news. The AutoGuide network operates more than 100 automotive forums where our users consult peers for shopping information and advice, and share opinions as a community.