Let me first say that I don't really know HOW running a site works these days, so correct these next points if I am wrong.
Granted, running a site is not free. That said, do you not get credit for every click made by every member, paying or not? When I sit here day after day clicking the active topics button, isn't that paying for the site?
I mean, there are 3 types of users here. The active ones who are VIP, The active ones who aren't VIP, and the people who stop by because they just bought a Legend, or have a question about one. I understand your wanting to "tax" those just stopping by to get quick answers, but it does seem sucky to the rest of us "active" non paying members. I feel like we are already "paying" for our time here with 1. our contributions ( we host our pics off photobucket!!) and 2. our clicks.
The adds on the left. You say you put them there to make them noticeable. These are the 4 adds I have On the left of my screen..
1. Acura RL Offical Site
2. Acura RL
3. The All-New 2010 Lexus RX
4. The New 2010 Volvo XC60
Maybe you don't want these adds to be so noticeable? I mean if I bought an RL, Lexus, or Volvo, I might not be coming to a Legend site so much anymore?
Ive decided that I will donate at this point, because I can't live with 100PMs or this bar on the left, but if this is the way you are going, I must strongly encourage you to have contests/rewards where you give away VIP status. Not often, but enough that active Contributors can possibly get memberships for their work.
Where would this site be right now without Telion, Car2n, Dv8, Sr5guy, Mike Diaz, etc?
Look at Car2ns LEGENDSX topic - 31,000 views.
Telions Turbo build - 28,000 views.
At a penny a view, thats $310 from Car2n and $280 from Telion. At 1/10th of a penny per click thats still 31 from car2n and 28 from Telion.
Basically, I am suggesting some sort of program that rewards the active contributors who make this site what it is. That is all.